Tuesday, November 04, 2008

Election Day Thoughts

Now and then I turn on the TV and, against my better judgment, flip to one of the twenty-four hour news networks. There’s been a lot of talk lately about how “stressful” this election is to many Americans. People are making appointments with psychotherapists to work through their fears that if the right guy doesn’t win, the world will go up in smoke.

I can’t say that I’ve always been very level-headed about these things myself, although for me, it’s a little bit different. I’ve been planning to vote for Obama from the outset, and just about every development since the primaries—not to mention every debate and every article I’ve read and discussion I’ve heard by professional wonks—has supported my conviction that this is probably the right decision. But then there’s this little voice in my head that says, "What if the McCain people are right? What if Obama is elected and the Middle East falls apart, capitalism collapses, and the world goes up in smoke? It’ll all be my fault." At this point, I remind myself about the electoral college, and how (to paraphrase a friend) every vote counts, but mine doesn’t matter.

Unfortunately, this does little to dispel the worry that I am a Traitor to the Jewish People. (I believe they call this “Jewish guilt.”) The argument goes something like this:

The difference is that unlike Shepherd Smith (who, for the record, is not exactly a left-wing reactionary), I tend to walk away from the conversation worrying that my position is the dangerous one. There’s no rational reason for this. It’s just a neurosis.

Well, today I am feeling less neurotic, and I’ve decided to share my thoughts on this subject. Of course, I’m not expecting to affect anyone’s vote at this point. You may even have already voted. But if you’re sick with worry over how an Obama win will result in the death of Israel, maybe this will calm you down some. (Probably not, but I can try.)

First, as Shepherd Smith pointed out, Obama has repeatedly emphasized the importance of the U.S.’s relationship with Israel. Does this mean anything? Probably not—every candidate does it—but it’s certainly unfair to say that Obama is anti-Israel. Nothing he’s said or done has demonstrated any ill-will toward the Jewish state.

Most of the focus of the “Obama equals death of Israel” argument has been on his stated willingness to “sit down” with Ahmadinejad, as well as other leaders whom he himself has pointedly labeled “America’s enemies.” In and of itself, this is not a controversial position. Our government has talks with enemy leaders all the time, and McCain has admitted that he would also pursue diplomatic relations with Iran and other countries. The argument between the candidates has been over “high-level” talks vs. lower-level talks and “preparation” vs. “preconditions.” There may be real differences here—it’s hard for someone like me to tell—but it’s certainly not the difference between being pro- or anti-Ahmadinejad. Both McCain and Obama have strongly criticized Ahmadinejad for his words on Israel, and both recognize him as an enemy.

The truth is, there’s only so much that the U.S. can do about the existence of countries and leaders that hate Israel and the Western World. We can’t “bomb Iran,” as McCain famously joked; we don’t have the resources for another war, and even if we did, it wouldn’t necessarily be a good idea. All we can do is speak softly and try to convince the world that we still have a big stick. Obama is generally better at speaking softly, while McCain is better at bragging about his stick. But in the end, I don’t think their policies would be very different.

One other matter has emerged recently, relating to an apparent relationship between Obama and Rashid Khalidi, an outspoken critic of Israel. According to the LA times, Obama has had dinner with Khalidi’s family a number of times and has remarked that the latter has encouraged him to consider his “blind spots and biases” and to continue the “conversation” with Palestinian leaders. To me, this sounds like pure politics and nothing much to worry about. But don’t take my word for it. Take Martin Perez’s:
I assume that my Zionist credentials are not in dispute. And I have written more appreciative words about Khalidi than Obama ever uttered. In fact, I even invited Khalidi to speak for a Jewish organization with which I work.

Moreover, the Israelis are trying to live cooperatively and in peace with Palestinians whose unrelenting positions make Khalidi almost appear like a Zionist.

I’m not saying that an Obama presidency would be better for Israel than a McCain presidency. I’m no foreign policy wonk, and there are many complicated issues involved. I’m just suggesting that we all take a deep breath here. Pour yourself a nice cup of tea or a glass of wine and watch the election results—or don’t. The world isn’t going to go up in smoke if it doesn’t work out the way you wanted. And even if it does, there isn’t much you can do about it now.


Jeremy said...


I've enjoyed reading your blog. I work in the Boston Jewish community and I'd like to tell you about an upcoming event. Can I send you an email about it?

Jeremy Goldberg
Geshercity Boston

Anonymous said...

Please stop believing the BS from the right.

Obama's Chieft of Staff is the son of member of the Irgun.


Jwerth said...

It's funny, the crazy right was worried that OBAMA had ties to terrorists--but all this time they were looking at the wrong guy! ;)

But in all seriousness, I'm incredibly excited that we'll have a chief of staff who cares so much about Israel (Rahm Emanuel actually took time off from his political career during the Gulf War to volunteer on an IDF army base!). Maybe we'll really see some peace process progress, at long last...

Anonymous said...

And now David Axelrod, a liberal Jew from New York's Lower East Side, joins the Obama administration.

Someday, I hope my friends who said President Obama would be bad for Israel wake up and start enjoying this...


elf said...

I've come to the realization that it's very rare for people to abandon strongly-held beliefs. Obama could appoint a whole cabinet of Jews -- even throw in a few Republicans -- and we'd still be hearing about how he's a terrorist-coddling anti-Semite.

I don't care anymore. The important thing is, he won, and now we'll have a president who isn't Bush. I am (guardedly) optimistic.

fleurdelis28 said...

A pro-Obama, pro-Israel friend, who has largely ceased to discuss politics with his pro-McCain parents -- and who is himself a registered Republican who previously voted for Bush, though not over Israel specifically -- sent his mother an e-mail titled something like 'Obama Linked to Terrorist Organization' about Emanuel's appointment. The record is silent regarding her reaction, though presumably she didn't appreciate it.

elf said...

funny :)

Mberenis said...

Obama has already made lending for middle and lower class citizens before he's in the white house! Amazing, read more below..

New Types of Low Interest Loans & Grants from Obama

Ben said...

I like your blog. I think Obama is a friend.Israel is too important for the world. This is Ben from Israeli Uncensored News

Anonymous said...















酒店喝酒 酒店消費 喝花酒 粉味 喝酒

Anonymous said...

designer fashion handbags
Louis Vuitton
designer fashion handbags
replica Louis Vuitton handbags
replica gucci handbags
replica hermes handbags
replica chanel handbags
designer fashion handbags
designer Louis Vuitton handbags
designer gucci handbags
designer hermes handbags
designer chanel handbags
designer fashion handbags
knockoff Louis Vuitton handbags
knockoff gucci handbags
knockoff hermes handbags
knockoff chanel handbags
designer fashion handbags
cheap Louis Vuitton handbags
cheap gucci handbags
cheap hermes handbags
cheap chanel handbags
designer fashion handbags
discount Louis Vuitton handbags
discount gucci handbags
discount hermes handbags
discount chanel handbags
Louis Vuitton outlet
gucci outlet
chanel purses
hermes birkin

Anonymous said...

Replica Prada Handbags , Fake MiuMiu Handbags , cheap chloe handbags , Discount Balenciaga handbags , wholesale jimmy choo handbags ,replica marc jacobs handbags ,discount christian dior bags ,Replica Fendi Handbags ,Copy Mulberry Handbags ,Bottega Veneta ,Replica DG Handbags ,wholesale thomas wylde handbags ,Replica Cartier Bags ,discount loewe handbags ,cheap coach handbags ,Replica YSL Handbags ,replica burberry handbags ,fake valention handbags ,fake versace handbags ,replica rolex men watches

Anonymous said...

fake rolex women watches ,replica omega watches ,fake jacob co watches,replica breitling watches ,tag heuer watches ,replica cartier watches ,fake panerai watches ,replica patek philippe watches ,replica vacheron constantin watches ,cheap audemars piguet watches ,replica alange sohne watches ,fake franck muller watches ,discount iwc watches ,replica jaeger lecoultre watches ,wholesale chopard watches ,replica mont blanc watches cheap rolex datejusts watches ,replica chanel watches ,fake gucci watches ,cheap christian louboutin shoes,fake christian louboutin pumps,discount christian louboutin sandals,wholesale christian louboutin boots

Anonymous said...

酒店經紀 酒店打工 酒店工作 酒店上班 酒店兼差 酒店兼職 打工兼差 打工兼職 酒店應徵 禮服店 酒店 經紀 打工 兼差 台北酒店 兼職

Nancy said...

I enjoyed the post. I could closely relate to it - these were exactly my thoughts and dilemmas back the.
Keep blogging - that way, we can connect!

This is Nancy from Israeli Uncensored News

George Tebresco said...

I'm trying to reach the writer of this blog but cannot find a way to send a note! I'm new to the blogosphere...How do I submit a private note?

George Tebresco

8105783376 Doorstep Massage Services in Bangalore said...

Bangalore Escort Service Agency
Escort Service in Bangalore
call girl service in Bangalore
Call girl in Bangalore
Adult Service in Bangalore
Independent Escort Bangalore
Independent Escort Bangalore service

8105783376 Doorstep Massage Services in Bangalore said...

Siliguri Escort Service
Siliguri Escort
Escort Service in Siliguri
Siliguri Escort Service Agency
Escort Siliguri
Call girl Service in Service
independent siliguri Escort Service
independent Escort Service

8105783376 Doorstep Massage Services in Bangalore said...

Vadodara Escort
Vadodara Escort Service
Escort Service in Vadodara
Vadodara Escort Ajency
Call girl Service in Vadodara
Call Girl Vadodara
Independent Vadodara escort
Independent Vadodara escort service

8105783376 Doorstep Massage Services in Bangalore said...

Surat Escort Service
Surat Escort
Surat Escort Service Ajency
Escort Service in Surat
Call Girl service in Surat
call gilr Surat
Indepndent surat escort service
independentsurat escort

8105783376 Doorstep Massage Services in Bangalore said...

Abu Dhabi Escort Service
Abu Dhabi Escort
Abu Dhabi Escort Service Ajency
Abu Dhabi Call girl Service
Escort Service in Abu Dhabi
call girl Abu Dhabi
independent abu dhabi escort service
independent abu dhabi escort